minimum wage Archives - Colorado Politics

Tony GagliardiTony GagliardiAugust 28, 20177min1726
Tony Gagliardi
Tony Gagliardi

All is quiet on the minimum-wage front at the moment, but don’t think last year’s passage of Amendment 70 is any long-term cease fire. Advocates for higher rates will kick off the 2018 session of the Colorado General Assembly with a push to let cities and counties set their own minimum-wage rates.

New research put out by the National Federation of Independent Business is worth every Colorado policymaker’s attention. The minimum wage is not the only issue measured by NFIB’s Small Business Poll, Job Openings, an update on the one published 10 years ago. Other interesting findings include:

  • One-quarter of small employers have an open position they are trying to fill
  • Of those open positions, 56 percent are full-time jobs, 44 percent part-time
  • The percentage of small employers citing lack of specific skills as the reason a job applicant is not qualified remains unchanged between the 2007 and 2017 polls
  • The attitude and appearance of job-seekers seems to have improved from poll to poll.

Work history, social skills, legal issues, wage expectations, English/math competencies, and drugs were other reasons for applicant disqualification. Only the last showed a slight increase over the 2007 poll.

How small employers advertise open positions, how they’re compensating employees, how they promote, how they’re dealing with federal immigration requirements are also asked. It is, however, questions on the minimum wage that are most valuable for state legislators, given their direct influence on it.

“Would a minimum wage increase to $15 phased in over the next 3 years have a negative impact, positive impact or no impact on your business?”

  • Businesses with 1 to 9 employees—44 percent negative; 6 percent positive; 42 percent no impact; 8 percent don’t know
  • 10 to 19 employees—58 percent negative; 4 percent positive; 29 percent no impact; 9 percent don’t know
  • 20-249 employees—60 percent negative; 3 percent positive; 19 percent no impact; 18 percent don’t know
  • All firms—47 percent negative; 5 percent positive; 39 percent no impact; 9 percent don’t know.

Taking the results from just the 1-to-9-employee group, the poll asked what immediate actions small-business owners take when hit with a minimum-wage increase. (Some would take simultaneous actions, which is why the percentages don’t add up to 100)

  • 84 percent would raise prices
  • 76 percent would take lower earnings
  • 69 percent would not fill an open position
  • 67 percent would increase wages
  • 62 percent would decrease the number of employees
  • 62 percent would reduce employees’ hours
  • 57 percent would increase the use of less expensive or part-time workers.

Amendment 70 is not as draconian as the proposed minimum-wage increase in the Job Openings poll. It increases the rate by 90 cents a year until 2020 when it would reach $12 an hour. Still, the coping actions being taken now by small-business owners are the same, mainly higher prices for consumers and loss of job opportunities, especially for teens and young adults.

It is forever worth reminding everyone that the minimum wage is earned by just 2.7 percent of the nation’s workers, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, and most of them tend to be young. “Although workers under age 25 represented only about one-fifth of hourly paid workers, they made up about half of those paid the federal minimum wage or less. Among employed teenagers (ages 16 to 19) paid by the hour, about 10 percent earned the minimum wage or less, compared with about 2 percent of workers age 25 and older.”

In short, the minimum wage is an entry-level wage earned mostly by teenagers and young adults. One major effect in increasing the minimum wage is eliminating entry-level jobs. Despite these facts, proponents of ever-increasing rates wrongly argue that they’re needed to lift people out of poverty, even though little to no evidence exists to back it up.

Not content with Amendment 70’s passage, minimum-wage advocates now want the Colorado Legislature to allow local governments the ability to set their own rates, which would create a crazy quilt of minimum-wage rates throughout the state and a commensurate paperwork migraine for every business.

If NFIB’s recent poll reminds of us of anything, it’s that costs have consequences.


Peter MarcusPeter MarcusJune 16, 20176min3535

A recent University of Colorado study backs up many of the arguments made by businesses who opposed raising the minimum wage in Colorado.

The study, published in the journal Regional Science and Urban Economics in May, comes after Colorado voters last November backed gradually raising the minimum wage to $12 per hour by 2020.

The first increase happened in January when the state minimum wage jumped to $9.30 per hour. Prior to that, the minimum wage stood at $8.31 per hour.

In 2018 the wage will jump to $10.20 per hour; $11.10 per hour in 2019; and finally $12 per hour in 2020.

The University of Colorado study, authored by Terra McKinnish, a professor in the Department of Economics, surprisingly found that low-wage workers commute away from states that raise the minimum wage, suggesting that wage-hiking initiatives cause employers to either cut payroll or look for alternatives.

“By making low-skilled workers more expensive, there is the potential for employers to use fewer workers, switch to slightly higher-skilled workers or exchange capital technology — such as self-serve kiosks — for low-skilled workers,” McKinnish said.

The labor economist called it a “disemployment effect.”

But supporters of raising wages across the states question whether the study offers an accurate snapshot. McKinnish looked at census data for 93 labor markets in 23 states where low-skilled workers commonly cross state borders for work.

She assessed out-of-state commuting rates for workers making less than $10 per hour compared to workers making between $10 and $13 per hour, from 2005 to 2008. There was no evidence that low-wage workers commuted at higher rates to neighboring states with a higher minimum wage.

The author then examined data between 2010 and 2011 after a federal minimum wage increase to $7.25 per hour prompted several states to boost their minimum wage, which resulted in less disparity between states.

The last time voters approved a minimum wage hike in Colorado prior to last year was in 2006, when the electorate adopted a wage of $6.85. It was adjusted to $8.31 per hour due to inflation.

“If low-wage workers were previously attracted to commute across state lines in order to receive a higher minimum wage, we would expect the rise in their own state’s minimum wage, relative to that of the neighbor’s, to reduce the rate of out-of-state commuting,” McKinnish said.

But the opposite was found. While moderate-wage workers were more inclined to stay in state, low-wage workers increasingly commuted out. On average, a $1.50 increase in a state’s minimum wage corresponded to as much as a 50 percent increase in the number of low-wage workers commuting out, the study found.

Michelle Webster, manager of research and policy analysis for the Colorado Center on Law and Policy, questioned why the study would have used data between 2010 and 2011, when the economic downturn was showing dire impacts on jobs.

“In 2010 and 2011, many states were still dealing with the effects of the recession, particularly low-wage workers. So I don’t know to what extent she controlled for that and controlled for how particular states were hit harder by the recession based on the industries that made up their economy,” Webster said.

“You can imagine that workers are crossing state lines just to work, and it’s not a function of employers necessarily pulling back on hiring because of the minimum wage, but just dealing with the continuing sluggish economy.”

While Colorado bounced back from the downturn faster than other states, it didn’t return to pre-recession job levels until about 2012. Nationally, jobs numbers didn’t return to pre-recession levels until 2014.

It’s still too early to evaluate any impact on the minimum wage increase in Colorado, though proponents are hopeful that since Colorado’s economy continues to improve, low-wage workers will also see benefits, thereby improving the state’s overall economy.

“I suspect that if the economy continues to do well, then the minimum wage increase in Colorado is only going to support that wage story and continue to lift up the wages of those lowest paid workers in Colorado,” Webster said.

During the debate over raising the minimum wage in Colorado, businesses said it would result in layoffs, reduced hours and fewer benefits.

Employers also said they would have to pass increased costs on to consumers. They argued that small businesses would be hurt the most, especially in rural parts of the state, where economic recovery has been slower.

Some business groups feel vindicated by the University of Colorado study.

“The research confirms the crux of the opposition to Amendment 70 – that such a poorly drafted law, written by out-of-state special interests, will hit rural areas hardest,” said Tyler Sandberg, former campaign manager for Keep Colorado Working, which fought against the wage hike. “Economic policy is complicated and the simplistic one-size-fits-all measure forced into our constitution was exactly the wrong way to address the minimum wage in Colorado.”

Joey BunchJoey BunchApril 15, 20173min103
Bad bosses, listen up: If you rip off employees — pinch their tips, pay less than minimum wage, deny overtime or jilt them on expenses — that’s no longer a “trade secret” but now a matter of public record in Colorado. This week Gov. John Hickenlooper put another notch in the legislative pistol of Rep. Jessie Danielson, […]

This content is only available to subscribers.

Login or Subscribe


Mike McKibbinMike McKibbinMarch 21, 20175min1540

Here's a whatever-happened-to update: If you remember Martha Ezzard from her time as a Colorado legislator, you should probably check out the story in the Denver Business Journal. A couple of decades ago, Ezzard and her husband, Dr. John Ezzard, moved to Georgia to run an Ezzard family farm. They turned it into a pretty successful winery and are now selling it and moving back to Colorado. Welcome back, Martha and John!


Mike McKibbinMike McKibbinDecember 30, 201613min141

For Colorado residents hunting for jobs that pay enough to live on, reports of the state's low unemployment rate and rapid population growth can be very disheartening. It seems everyone else has a job except you, often a depressing thought. However, a recent study digs deeper into the numbers and finds job hunters' perceptions of the state's employment situation being less positive than as portrayed are closer to reality. And state lawmakers will be presented with the study's findings, in hopes of doing something to help workers and job hunters.


Adam McCoyAdam McCoyDecember 29, 201628min135

Symbolic of the divisiveness of our politics, many Coloradans will look back at the 2016 election with violent contempt, reflecting on a political year that saw the rise of President-elect Donald Trump, while others will reminisce with sublime glee over a cycle where voters bucked the political establishment. In a year full of tectonic shifts on the national political landscape, Colorado had its share of drama and surprises, though voters sent back many familiar faces to serve in Congress and at the state Capitol. Here’s your bite-size, highlight reel for the 2016 election season in Colorado.


Rachael WrightRachael WrightDecember 15, 201612min140

Twenty Years Ago this week in The Colorado Statesman … Republican Secretary of State Victoria Buckley found herself under a bit of a microscope with the legislative branch. Buckley was forced to defend her campaign's actions, coming under fire by the Colorado General Assembly's Audit Committee. The state auditor had released a report finding that Buckley had accepted campaign contributions from organizations and individuals the secretary of state's office was responsible for regulating: bingo and raffle operators. Serving her first term at the time, Buckley took issue with the auditor’s recommendation that she not solicit or accept contributions from people she regulated. Neither the state constitution nor Colorado election laws prohibited such things, Buckley said. In her opinion, this included the incident she was being criticized for: accepting proceeds from a $500-per-couple fundraiser thrown by lobbyist Freda Poundstone. Some of the people Poundstone had invited to the event were bingo and raffle operators as well as the landlords of properties where those games were played.


Associated PressAssociated PressNovember 29, 20161min2470

Workers at a Denver McDonald's plan to strike and then demonstrate at the city's airport on Tuesday as part of a nationwide day of protests by fast-food employees to push for higher wages and union rights. While a strike is planned at Chicago's O'Hare International Airport, the Service Employees International Union says workers won't try to disrupt operations at Denver International Airport. It says the goal is to hand out fliers to passengers and airport workers pushing for better working conditions there.


Wellington WebbWellington WebbNovember 15, 201614min1670

As we begin to digest the 2016 election results, let me begin with our successes. First, I want to congratulate Denver voters on our 80 percent turnout, which is outstanding. I also want to congratulate Emmy Ruiz for running a great campaign in Colorado for Hillary Clinton. She helped make Colorado blue and bring Hillary our vote. Emmy was calm throughout the campaign, met with everyone she needed to and kept focus. It’s unfortunate we didn’t have more people like her nationwide. I’m also glad Denver and metro voters endorsed continuing the tax on the Scientific and Cultural Facilities District along with the Denver Public Schools bond proposal. Additionally, it was gratifying voters statewide understood the need to protect our Constitution and endorsed Amendment 71.

Colorado PoliticsColorado PoliticsNovember 14, 201620min1130

DENVER — “It’s just another manic Monday …” Thank you, Bangles. Here’s hoping that your Monday is off to a good start. It's sure to be an interesting week in both state and national politics as new agendas and appointments are announced. Possibly more interesting could be new alliances and political ‘break-ups.’ Before getting on with the Hot Sheet for today, we wanted to share a possibly poignant moment from this weekend’s Saturday Night Live. SNL host Dave Chappelle took a moment to wish Donald Trump luck and expressed his hopes that the White House would remain open to everyone. Did you CATCH IT?